Soccer Gaming has teamed up with Pro Evolution Soccer site, PES Gaming to deliver the
review
of PES 2012. Whilst this may seem like a slightly biased move, be
assured that reviewed, Dougie Donut has a reputation for not only
speaking his mind, but also being slightly underwhelmed by previous
Konami offerings. With that said, his lengthy and open review of PES 2012 will hopefully give the SG community something to think about when deciding whether to purchase that title.
Introduction
I’d like to begin my review by paying tribute to Konami staff, who have
managed to
work through one of the worst natural disasters they have ever faced in
their history. It could have been quite conceivable for Konami to have
either
cancelled or delayed the
game by 6 months to tackle their challenging situation, but somehow
showed strength in character to actually produce the game – despite the
almost surreal nature of their reality.
This review will be for
the core game of football. I plan on doing a Master League (+online) review shortly after this one.
For me, PES 2011 was a landmark version. It created the core game
which would finally sever it’s ties to the initial direction Konami took
with the current generation of machines. Whilst there was still too
much hand holding for my liking, it set the course for player freedom
which is definitely the way forward.
The
Breakdown
I thought I’d try to provide a comprehensive review of the key mechanics of the game. So I’ve tried to create categories of interest. What I’d like to achive with this review is to try to talk through the categories, and then to provide an overall impression and review of the game. So here goes.
Graphics
Whilst graphics are not high on my personal agenda by which to judge games, I did think PES 2011 was not
blessed in the looks department.This was more apparent when compared to
a certain rival game. But I’m pleased to say that the game looks very
polished.The player characters look very smooth, and the pitches are
pleasantly varied. Last year we had the same looking pitch in all
stadiums.But this year, we have different shades of pitches which makes
for better aesthetics. The addition of increased peripheral characters
in matches may appeal to some.I have to say that I’ve never been fond of
the elements to the game which look to provide superficial gloss.
Features in the past such as shirts that crease, or the new neck muscle
and eye bulging ferocity of players is lost on me. I’d rather extra
effort was put into the core game! But that said, the game is better looking.
Passing
For this review I have used mostly zero pass assistance when playing.
This for me gives a more authentic feel to the passing game. The demos
did not reflect the passing mechanics which are in the final game. Even
with full assistance, if you tap the pass button, you won’t
automatically get a perfect full length pass to a player further away
from you. A short pass will go towards a target player, but at a slower
pace, leaving it susceptible to interception.
My use of zero assistance gives me much more control over play, and
means that I end up with over hit and under hit passes during play. I
don’t find this frustrating at all, and if anything it brings a smile to
my face because I made those mistakes myself! I didn’t have automated
passing routines interpreting my intentions – I messed up of my own
accord. It’s been a long time in coming, but finally Konami have
delivered us authentic, fully user controlled passing. Thank you very
much Konami! I have to warn you though, that this will take some getting
used to.
You could try starting at the default 2/4 bars of assistance and
reduce the levels as you get more comfortable with the game. What
becomes apparent during play is that under pressure you’re more likely
to make mistakes when passing the ball. This delivers a more authentic
experience, which is a real positive.
Shooting
Most
of my games have been played with lesser well known teams. This comes
with the limitation of not having players with brilliant stats for their
abilities. What it does do is give you a larger element of the unknown
with players that you are not so familiar with. Shooting with these
types of players feels very natural and you don’t always get perfectly
hit shots with serious power. What you do get is context sensitivity
playing a large part in whether the ball is struck properly or not. This
results in realistic shots being taken, where either power or accuracy
not being of a sufficient quality to trouble goalkeepers. But the
element of surprise is always there, since these players can score great
goals too, but not at will, as with the very top players.
This is another tribute to the authenticity the game has to offer.
Shooting with the usual suspects yields the usual results. You get well
struck shots which pack enough oomph to give you satisfaction. You can
use the finesse button ‘R2′ or ‘RT’ to superb effect too. It’s
definitely a feature you should incorporate in your game.
One feature which did dissappoint with the game was the lack of
ability to lob the ball. As much as I tried, I was unable to lob the
keeper. You get more of a lofted ball, which is easily picked off.
A big change from PES 2011 for shooting is that when you’re
attacking, having an opponent in close proximity doesn’t necessarily
affect your shots. You can use your strength and positioning to great
effect. This adds more emphasis to the defensive aspects of the game,
which I’ll talk about shortly.
Dribbling
Dribbling, which most of you will be familiar with from the demos, is
very satisfying indeed. The dribbling is reminiscent of dribbling from
the likes of PES5/6. Without using tricks, you can jink, shuffle, burst
past, or just plain old stop and lay the ball off with fully reactive
players. There’s no feeling of button lag, or response lag to your
instructions. The players are totally responsive to you, and this really
does make you feel at home with the game.
The use of tricks adds another dimension to the game which more
advanced players will no doubt master. But it’s not necessary to do so.
You can just use the basics to control and manipulate players to carry
out your will.
Something of concern though is the dribbling ability of key star
players. There’s a noticeable difference in controlling and dribbling
with star players who outshine lesser players. This could lead to
beating several men fairly easily, but by mastering the defensive
techniques available, this should be counter-balanced.
I should also add that when I have tried playing as Barcelona against
poor teams, I was not able to dominate with Messi. I would find him
getting double-teamed by players to try to halt his progress. This is
not to say that he was rendered totally ineffective, but it wasn’t easy
going for Messi. Of course this is just against CPU, and so playing
against real opponents will be more of a challenge in terms of your
dribbling skills versus your opponents defending skills.
Attacking
Since playing primarily on Top Player mode, as well as occasionally on SuperStar level, attacking is not easy.
You will need to adapt to the play as it unfolds in front of you. You
will have a good feel for this from the demo already. I would recommend
spending a couple of games getting to know how your team functions.
Understanding which players make supporting runs or create space to
understand when a goal threat opportunity presents itself will be key to
your success. You can attempt to bulldoze your way through the middle
with key passes or dribblers with mixed results, or you can play a more
patient game waiting for an opening to be made, and then to go for it.
Alternatively wing play can be used very effectively. I’d go so far
as to say too effectively. I’ve been scoring a fair few of my goals from
comfortable crosses which tend to get converted more often than not.
It’s going to be a challenge to stop those crosses from coming in this
year.
A bit like the cut back passes of old which were pretty much
unstoppable with the right players. But it’s not a game killer in my
opinion, but will require some level of skill to stop your opponents
from picking up easy goals. And yet again, I nearly forgot to mention
using the right stick to trigger runs! I have to say I’ve only used the
assisted mode yet. So I’ve only been selecting a player to trigger his
run, and not controlled the player myself. With so much movement on the
pitch, and with your general passing abilities, it’s easy to forget that
you can trigger runs to create more space for yourself. It’s a feature
that is a Godsend in my opinion. We’ve all sworn at a defender or
midfielder in the past who just stood there and watched you struggle
with the ball when attacking. Those days are gone.
Defending
Defending is very diverse now. We have effectively four different ways to defend:
1. We can use brute force by applying pressure on to a striker, but
expect to give away many soft free kicks as a result (via the ‘X’ or ‘A’
buttons).
2. We can slide tackle – it’s a last ditch approach and very maverick
to use as the main defence tactic, so expect plenty of cards if you do
this a lot.
3. We can use the new jockeying system – this will take some time to
master, and even then it’s not guaranteed to be very effective. Factors
such as timing, defensive ability as well as sheer luck will all combine
to hopefully stop attacks (using Right trigger or R2 button with ‘X’ or
‘A’).
4. We can call in reinforcements to try to steal the ball, but again you may be susceptible to giving away free kicks.
It’s great to now have different methods to help you repel attacks
from your opponents. It’s not easy, and will require quick judgement
calls, as well as working on your defensive skills. I’d say that this
game is probably a little more biased towards attacking play, but
defenders should have enough in their arsenal to match them.
But make no mistake, defending is a skill which you will have to
learn to master all over again. You’ll give away many unnecessary free
kicks, pick up bookings and generally be very annoyed when off the ball
until you get a better grasp of the game. It’s back to basics with
defending.
Something I haven’t quite got a handle on is seeing a central
defender making challenges in the middle of the park on occasion. It’s
weird to see him abandon his station at the heart of the defence and
become a maverick on the field. This may happen a fair bit, and I’m not
sure if it’s because of my team formation and set up. Thinking about it,
one strategy is for a centre back to join attacking play. But I don’t
recall initiating the strategy. It’s something I’ll try to keep an eye
on, and I’m sure you guys will let me know if it’s an issue!
Set pieces
The right analog stick has now been enhanced to allow you to control
alternative players to the set piece taker, as I’m sure you’re all aware
of. What I learned whilst playing is that you don’t have to wait to
place your player before delivering him the ball. So you can get him
running into position and play the ball to allow him to get a running
jump at the ball – at corners for example. Since it is obvious which
player is making the run, it’s fairly easy for your opponent to pick out
who to man mark.
To get around this you can trigger a dummy run to create space, then
revert back to controlling the set piece taker to deliver the ball
anywhere else – such as the space the dummy runner created. So this opens up the strategic elements to set pieces a bit more.
Free Kicks
I really like the free kick system. It’s pretty much unchanged from
last year, which I had no complaints about. However when playing against
the CPU, there’s a major bug there in my opinion. If you give away a
free kick around 18 to 21 yards roughly from goal, expect to pick the
ball up from the back of the net. It’s really annoying to see virtually
every attempt go in and be so helpless. Placing a defender on the line
makes no difference.
In fact during free kicks it dawned on me that it would have been
good to be able to control the keeper’s placement on the line manually.
Sure it leaves you potentially more vulnerable to a well taken free
kick, but against the AI, when you know exactly where the ball will be
put, it would have saved a sure goal. If the success rate of these free
kicks could be toned down to have around a 15 to 20% success rate for
CPU teams, then it would easier to digest. Free kicks from further
distances are much more realistic and so you can live with goals going
in from them.
Active AI
I have to admit that when I read the blurb about Active AI, I was
left underwhelmed. I was reassured that I would be impressed by it, and I
have to say, I really am. I’ve been playing the game with the blimp
camera mode a fair bit to just watch my team mates around me.
Possession football is a big part of my game, and means I will pass
it back as much as I do forward. But wherever I choose to pass the
balls, my players are alert to my positioning and move to offer
themselves, or to create space. I’m still getting used to the types of
running that they do. They finally feel alert and alive! Playing with
different teams reflects the ‘game intelligence’ of players around you.
Don’t expect lesser teams to have the movement abilities of better
teams. But they do still offer good positioning.
Goalkeepers
Once again goalkeepers can be great and occassionally poor in their
decision making. Some rather tame shots are parried into open play,
where it would have been easier to just catch it. But other times there
have been good saves and interceptions from keepers.
Overall they’re better than last year, but in the grand scheme of
things, they’re still a remnant of goalkeeping from the last generation
of PES games.
You can bet that they will be given a complete overhaul for next
year’s edition. I have to say that I’m so overjoyed that you can now
make your goalkeeper deliver the ball to any outfield player you wish
to. It’s been something that has bugged me for years, and finally it’s
wonderful to see this ability in the game!
Referees
So far I’ve found referees to be a bit of a mixed bag. I think there
are different types of refereeing principles in use for different types
of games. For single player games against the CPU, I found that if I
committed off the ball challenges, I invariably got away with them.
This was very dissappointing, since it was a problem from last year that I was hoping would be fixed.
But then when playing two player games, off the ball challenges were
always given as fouls, and carded where appropriate too. I’ve been the
recipient of what I would call a very harsh red card once, for a sliding
tackle which I didn’t think was too bad. I haven’t received a red card
since in play. I’ve been given fair yellow cards throughout, and
justifiably so.
We see the return to the series of free kicks for running into
players, or applying pressure to them without any finesse or strategy.
Some may be frustrated with this, but hopefully you can learn the bounds
of the principles referees are applying fairly quickly to know what you
can and can’t do. What is good is that the refereeing decisions are
generally consistent. So there’s no excuse for throwing a wobbly at
referees.
Referees also let play continue for as long as they can to give the
fouled player’s team the advantage before calling back play if the move
breaks down. It helps keep the action a bit more fluid, especially given
how start stop games can be.
Presentation
The
new slicker presentation from last year has been built on and refined
for the new version. When you first boot up the game, you are invited to
create a player profile. In it you create an avatar for yourself and
set up your control system preferences. From creating your preferred
link feints to setting passing assistance, all your settings are done up
front and carried in to the game. You do not get the opportunity to
change your link feints in game, as the formation screen menus have been
changed.
There are four formations you can set to allow you to create your
custom strategies to take into games. It should be noted that you can
create different profiles for yourself to allow you work with different
set ups
